ARCHIVED
ISSUS - May 2001
Vol. 82 No. 9
The
Jewish Traveler:
Recife
By Alan M. Tigay
Four hundred years after the first visit
of the Inquisition to northeastern Brazil, Jewish life is
center stage.
History
Community
Sights
Personalities
Recommendations
The people of Recife, capital of the Brazilian state of
Pernambuco, are grandiose when talking about their city. In
the local view of things, the Beberibe and Capibaribe Rivers
flow through the city and then meet—forming the Atlantic
Ocean. a Briefly ruled by the Dutch in the seventeenth century,
Recife enjoyed a golden age, funded by the sugar industry, in
which Jews flourished and built the first synagogue in the
Americas. Now, more than 350 years later, that synagogue has
been restored, to the acclaim of not only the entire city: In
keeping with the local bent for hyperbole, enthusiastic guides
routinely tell visitors that the Jews who left Recife founded
not just the Jewish community of New York—surely no small
claim—but New York itself.
History
In
the 1530’s, Portugal’s King João III divided Brazil into
16 commercial territories called captaincies. The captaincy of
Pernambuco was given to Duarte Coelho, friend to many New
Christians—as descendents of converted Jews were known.
Pernambuco was the most profitable of the captaincies and the
mainstay of the economy was sugar, with New Christians running
about half the colony’s sugar mills. Planters typically kept
a manor house on their plantations and a town house in Olinda
(four miles north of modern Recife), which was the capital
under the Portuguese.
More than half the New Christians in
sixteenth-century Pernambuco were secret Jews, supporting at
least 10 clandestine synagogues. Small groups met in private
homes for Shabbat, while larger groups gathered in secret
chapels on the sugar plantations—farther from the eyes of
neighbors—on major festivals. The Inquisition came to
northeastern Brazil in 1591 and many of the colony’s secret
Jews were sent to Lisbon for trial.
In 1630 the Dutch captured Pernambuco
and transferred the capital to Recife, which had a better port.
In addition to the Jews who came as immigrants, crypto-Jews
already in the colony came into the open. In 1641, the first
synagogue building in the Americas—Kahal Zur Israel—was
constructed on the Rua dos Judeus (Street of the Jews).
Despite anti-Jewish agitation from Dutch Calvinists and
Portuguese Catholics, the ruler of Dutch Recife, Count Maurice
of Nassau, saw to it that Jewish rights were upheld. Under
Dutch rule, Jews came to number about 1,400—half the colony’s
free population. Most were involved with sugar as planters,
brokers, exporters or financiers. The first rabbi in the New
World, Isaac Aboab da Fonseca, arrived in 1641 from Amsterdam.
When the Netherlands ceded Pernambuco
back to Portugal in 1654, Jews—fearful of a newly imposed
Inquisition—left. Most went back to Holland or to the
Caribbean, where they planted the seeds of a new sugar
industry. One group of 23 was captured by Spanish pirates.
Eventually rescued in Jamaica, they were put on a French ship
headed for the Dutch colony of New Amsterdam. It was this
group that formed the nucleus of what would become the largest
Jewish community in history. New York’s Congregation
Shearith Israel is a direct descendent of Kahal Zur Israel.
Some of Recife’s Jews did not leave
with the Dutch but went back underground. The Inquisition
rooted out secret Jews in Brazil’s northeast for another 200
years, by which time Jewish practice had supposedly died out.
In recent years, however, many people of Jewish descent have
emerged. Depending on whom one talks to and which definition
is employed, Jewish descendents number anywhere from dozens to
hundreds of thousands.
In the twentieth century a new Jewish
community formed in Recife. It began in the 1920’s with
immigrants from the shtetls of Russia and Bessarabia and
continued in the 1930’s with a more urbanized immigration
from Hungary, Romania, Germany and Austria. Beginning as
peddlers and shopkeepers, they produced a small but vibrant
Jewish culture that included not only organizational life but
Yiddish theater and newspapers as well.
Community
Recife
has two overlapping Jewish communities. The mainstream is
primarily descended from the twentieth-century immigrants.
Their communal center is the Centro Israelita, in the city’s
Torre section, at Rua José de Hollanda 798. Among the
institutions housed in the Centro are Renascer (“rebirth”),
a liberal congregation that holds Friday-night services; the
umbrella organization of the community, the Federação
Israelita de Pernambuco and a Jewish school. For information
on the community, call school director Marcel Kosminsky at
55-81-3227-0418.
Jews live primarily in the Torre, Casa
Forte, Madalena and Graças neighborhoods and along Boa Viagem
Beach. The children of the immigrants became doctors,
engineers and architects; the grandchildren spread deeper into
the professional sector. Though still a cohesive community of
about 1,500, intermarriage stands at 70 percent.
The second community is that of the
Anousim—descendents of crypto-Jews, many of whom now
identify or practice openly as Jews. Their religious center is
the synagogue essentially abandoned but still owned by the
mainstream community and located at Rua Martins Junior 29, in
a neighborhood that once had many Jewish residents and
businesses. The synagogue has Saturday morning services and
congregants often come back for an afternoon Torah lesson.
(For information on services, call Isaac Essoudry at
3465-8827.)
Three years ago a rabbi from Belo
Horizonte, 1,500 miles to the south, began making periodic
trips to Recife to perform conversions. About 15 families of
Anousim have formally joined the community based at the Centro
Israelita. Others are either in the process of converting or
believe conversion is unnecessary.
The encounter between the groups has
been a combination of warm embrace and misunderstanding. Some
look at the former Anousim and see an inspiring Jewish story;
others welcome them but have no notion of their past or of the
greater number of Anousim outside their view. Some of the
Anousim—hardly united themselves—speak of rejection by the
mainstream community.
Recife’s third congregation is the
Chabad Center (3325-3733). Though there is no Lubavitch
community per se, the center’s location in Boa Viagem, the
neighborhood with the largest concentration of Jews, attracts
many to its Shabbat services and its school.
Despite their small numbers, Recife’s
Jews are the focus of the city’s attention these days.
Locals view the Dutch period with pride and regard Nassau as a
great builder from whom today’s politicians can learn. Until
five years ago, the two islands that form the center of old
Recife were run-down and dangerous. The restoration of the
synagogue is part of the city’s renaissance. The synagogue
restoration, the emergence of Anousim and recent research on
the colonial period are putting the Jewish story into the
center of a rich regional stew of culture and folklore that
includes music (forró and frevo), tales of heroes and bandits,
and Recife’s own brand of Carnaval.
The Jewish place in Brazil’s history
and culture was barely known before the twentieth century. The
Recife-born sociologist Gilberto Freyre, one of the first to
treat Brazil’s multiracial character as a strength, was also
the first to recognize the sizable Jewish element in Brazil’s
population. (Recently two of Freyre’s grandchildren had DNA
tests, which showed the probability of Jewish ancestry.) In
1996, José Antônio Gonçalves de Mello published the
documentary history People of the Nation: New Christians and
Jews in Pernambuco, 1542-1654. The Federal University of
Pernambuco has a new program in Jewish studies; when the
program’s director, Tânia Kaufman, published The Jewish
Presence in Pernambuco last winter, it could immediately be
seen in the windows of the city’s bookstores.
Sights
In the center of Old Recife is the Rua
de Bom Jesus, nowadays also identified by its original name,
Rua dos Judeus. Gentrification has turned the street into a
cultural and entertainment hub, with constant traffic to and
from the restaurants, sidewalk cafés and nightspots. The
buildings are mostly colonial-era edifices painted green,
yellow, blue and tan. In the middle of the street’s west
side, at number 197/203, is the restored Kahal Zur Israel
Synagogue, scheduled to be reinaugurated this month. The
synagogue is a yellow stone, two-story building with arched
ochre doors and windows and iron railings.
The synagogue now houses the Jewish
Cultural Center of Pernambuco. Inside, the ground level
reveals the original synagogue floor (at least a foot below
the level of today’s floor) and the mikve, discovered by
archaeologists before the restoration work began. In addition
to what is visible below the floor, the ground level will be
largely devoted to the cultural center’s exhibits.
As in the Dutch period, when the ground
level consisted of shops, the rebuilt sanctuary will be on the
second floor. The center will also have a historic archive and
research center. For information on the center and its
programs, call Marcel Kosminsky or e-mail Tânia Kaufman at
tnkaufman@aol.com.
Up the street from Kahal Zur Israel is
the Malakoff Tower, a cultural center and observatory. The
tower is said to be built from stones taken from the arched
entries that stood at each end of the Rua dos Judeus.
Across the bridges on the neighboring
island of Antonio Vaz are several spots of Jewish interest.
Among the most beautiful historic buildings are the Governor’s
House, the Palace of Justice and the Santa Isabel Theater, all
of which surround the Praça da Republica. All stand on land
once occupied by Vrijburg Palace, a residence and seat of
government built mainly by Jewish architects and engineers for
Count Maurice of Nassau.
Recife is as proud of its bridges as it
is of its beaches, and two of the spans linking Antonio Vaz
island with the mainland have Jewish connections. The Duarte
Coelho Bridge is named for the man who brought so many New
Christians to Pernambuco in the sixteenth century. Two short
blocks away is the blue-and-gold Boa Vista Bridge, the oldest
span in Brazil, built in the 1640’s by the Jewish engineer
Baltasar da Fonseca—according to legend, after his father
drowned while crossing the river. This bridge connects the Rua
Nova, a bustling semipedestrian mall that had many Jewish
residents during the Dutch period, and Rua Imperatriz, which
had Jewish residents in the colonial era and again in the
twentieth century.
Most of Recife’s neighborhoods and
many surrounding suburbs take their names from the sugar mills
that once dotted the landscape. The oldest standing plantation
house is at Camaragibe, about 20 minutes from the city center.
Camaragibe was owned by Diogo Fernandes and Branca Dias, who
had a clandestine synagogue in their home that was used on
major Jewish holidays.
The plantation’s manor house still
stands, although it is difficult to tell what, beyond the
foundation, is from the sixteenth century. The charming pink
house is surrounded by dense vegetation that protects it from
the town that now bears its name. Though it is a private home,
visitors routinely walk the grounds, and those who state a
good reason may be admitted inside.
The house features dark wooden floors
and a dining room table that seats at least 20. The current
owners are Catholics, but the ground-floor family chapel is in
all likelihood either the same room or on top of a basement
chapel that was once the secret Jewish sanctuary.
The chapel itself has painted blue tiles
on one wall bearing a likeness of its patron saint, Santiago.
A seam on the stone floor under the carpet is suggestive of a
long-sealed trap door, but an employee who escorts visitors
says the basement has been closed for years. Adjacent to the
chapel is a hallway door which he says once led to a stairway
but is now a closet. Across from the closet is the library, in
which a visitor’s eye falls easily on a shelf of Jewish
books, including the Portuguese Antologia Judaica and a copy
of The World of Sholem Aleichem in English. In the absence of
more research, the imagination works overtime.
Ten minutes north of Recife is Olinda—the
capital of Pernambuco during the first Portuguese period—which
still has its sixteenth-century layout and charm. The city,
declared a World Heritage Site by UNESCO, has cobblestone
streets lined with pastel-colored buildings. The center of
Olinda is perched on a hill, which affords magnificent views
of the fig and palm trees that surround the tile rooftops, and
of the ocean and Recife in the distance.
The main street of Olinda is Rua Bispo
Coutinho, and its most prominent landmark is the Igreja da
Miseracórdia, which is likely where the Inquisition was
seated in the 1590’s. Just up the street from the church, at
No. 526, is a white house with yellow trim that is believed to
occupy the site of Diogo Fernandes and Branca Dias’s town
house. In addition to its clandestine synagogue, the house was
also where Dias conducted the first school in Brazil, in which
she taught sewing, embroidery and cooking to young girls.
Just down the street, at the top of an
incline called Ladeira da Misericórdia (Hillside of Pity)
stands a white and green building that houses Academia Santa
Gertrude, a Catholic girls’ school. In the sixteenth century
the site was occupied by several houses of Jews who were
denounced to the Inquisition.
Personalities
The outstanding Jewish figure in
Pernambuco’s history is Branca Dias, who spent 15 months in
an Inquisition prison in her native Portugal and was denounced
again after her death. In addition to the factual Dias, there
are two legendary heroines of the same name, likely based on
the historic Dias. According to Paulo Valadares, a leading
Jewish genealogist, among the real Branca Dias’s many
descendents today are Ciro Gomes, a potential presidential
contender in 2002, and Chico Buarque da Holanda, one of the
leading composers of Brazilian popular music.
The earliest Brazilian literature was
written by Jews in Olinda. Bento Texeira Pinto wrote Prosopopéa,
the first collection of poems, and Ambrósio Brandão authored
the first history of the land. Four hundred years later,
Recife produced Clarisse Lispector, one of contemporary Brazil’s
most popular novelists. Another twentieth-century figure is
Dr. Noel Nutels, known for his work with the Indians of
northern Brazil.
Recommendations
Though the city’s main cultural
attractions are in the center.
Unless you speak Portuguese, it’s best
to travel with a guide. Aside from getting you to the sights,
a local will help you distinguish between the city’s
fantastic past and present, and its even more fantastic
exaggerations.
|